Skip over navigation
In mathematics it is often useful to have different ways of viewing concepts in order to help to build up intuition; however we need to know to what extent analogies are mathematically trust-worthy. Imagine the following proposals for analogies concerning calculus -- some might be good analogies, some might sometimes work and some might simply not work at all.
Consider and test these proposed analogies for understanding aspects of calculus carefully, applying them to several examples. Which analogies are largely sound, and which fail to work? Provide examples of functions to exemplify your points.
Analogy: A curve is a road on a map
Imagine an analogy where the curve of a function represents a road drawn on a map. Imagine driving along this road, starting from the left (west)
1. Sign of the derivative of a function at each point
The derivative of the function is positive when travelling towards the north, negative when travelling towards the south.
2. Sign of the second derivative of a function at each point
If your steering wheel is turned clockwise from the neutral position then the second derivative is negative. If it is turned anticlockwise from the neutral position then the second derivative at that point is positive.
3. Sign of the third derivative of a function at each point
If the steering wheel is in the process of turning in the anti clockwise direction then the third derivative is positive. If the steering wheel is in the process of turning in the clockwise direction then the third derivative is negative.
4. Differentiability condition at each point
The function is differentiable at points on the road when is it possible to drive along smoothly without having to suddenly turn the steering wheel.
5. Points of inflection
Points of inflection occur at the points, and only the points, where the steering wheel passes through the neutral position.
Note on terminology: The 'neutral position' is the position of the steering wheel in which the car travels forwards in a straight line. A clockwise turn from this position causes the car to turn right and an anticlockwise turn from this position causes the car to turn left.
Calculus Analogies
Age 16 to 18
Challenge Level 
In mathematics it is often useful to have different ways of viewing concepts in order to help to build up intuition; however we need to know to what extent analogies are mathematically trust-worthy. Imagine the following proposals for analogies concerning calculus -- some might be good analogies, some might sometimes work and some might simply not work at all.
Consider and test these proposed analogies for understanding aspects of calculus carefully, applying them to several examples. Which analogies are largely sound, and which fail to work? Provide examples of functions to exemplify your points.
Analogy: A curve is a road on a map
Imagine an analogy where the curve of a function represents a road drawn on a map. Imagine driving along this road, starting from the left (west)
1. Sign of the derivative of a function at each point
The derivative of the function is positive when travelling towards the north, negative when travelling towards the south.
2. Sign of the second derivative of a function at each point
If your steering wheel is turned clockwise from the neutral position then the second derivative is negative. If it is turned anticlockwise from the neutral position then the second derivative at that point is positive.
3. Sign of the third derivative of a function at each point
If the steering wheel is in the process of turning in the anti clockwise direction then the third derivative is positive. If the steering wheel is in the process of turning in the clockwise direction then the third derivative is negative.
4. Differentiability condition at each point
The function is differentiable at points on the road when is it possible to drive along smoothly without having to suddenly turn the steering wheel.
5. Points of inflection
Points of inflection occur at the points, and only the points, where the steering wheel passes through the neutral position.
Note on terminology: The 'neutral position' is the position of the steering wheel in which the car travels forwards in a straight line. A clockwise turn from this position causes the car to turn right and an anticlockwise turn from this position causes the car to turn left.
You may also like
Folium of Descartes
Investigate the family of graphs given by the equation x^3+y^3=3axy for different values of the constant a.
Witch of Agnesi
Sketch the members of the family of graphs given by y = a^3/(x^2+a^2) for a=1, 2 and 3.
